Why Do Felons Still Get Guns So Easily?
Josiah Graves’ background directly challenges the redneck gun-owner stereotype. Jerremy Alexander Newsome and Dave Conley highlight alarming veteran suicide rates and argue despair, not guns, is the real driver. Founders explicitly allowed gun regulations. Current enforcement frustrates everyone—many felons still get firearms because background checks aren’t rigorous enough. Debate shifts to whether evil, not the tool, is the core issue. Gun safety courses get compared to continuing medical education. No one lands on an easy fix.
Timestamps:
- (13:09) Gun owners need continuing education like doctors – skills rust, risks rise
- (14:01) Basic hunter safety works – so why settle for one-and-done training?
Connect:
- Josiah Graves – Website
🌍 Connect with us: Instagram | YouTube | X
🎧 Listen to Episodes → Here
Transcript
"I'm the ignorant redneck??!"
2
:— Josiah's résumé shatters it quick...
3
:Jerremy drops veteran
suicide numbers though...
4
:and the claim lands plain:
despair drives it, not the tool.
5
:Dave: So I'd like to dig into this a
little bit to transition us into solutions
6
:there is no doubt that the founders
beat the biggest empire on earth with
7
:privately owned warships and cannons.
8
:And they wrote that Second Amendment
just a few days after requiring
9
:every man to own a military rifle.
10
:It was the AR 15 of their day The
other part of this is the founders
11
:also let towns confiscate guns,
particularly from loyalists.
12
:Also, quote unquote disorderly persons.
13
:they banned Catholics.
14
:they let officers search your house.
15
:these were the laws of the time.
16
:today is different.
17
:Like we already know
felons can't own guns.
18
:Research does show that
some limits do work.
19
:Like I live in Florida waiting periods
even magazine limits, red flag laws,
20
:those do reduce the number of deaths.
21
:If anything, steelman the other
side of this, but tell me for
22
:you, does work, what doesn't work?
23
:Is it the libertarian, no constraints,
no laws or are there some fences, quote
24
:unquote, that make good neighbors?
25
:I think I wanna avoid the, all
the guns that seems, hyperbolic,
26
:that's not even possible.
27
:But tell me the other side of this.
28
:Tell me about fences, if anything.
29
:richie, you wanna start that one?
30
:Richie: so you said something there
that I literally i'm trying to take
31
:notes in case I think of something,
but you said felons can't hold guns
32
:Dave: that is actually among
the only national laws we
33
:have Felons can't own guns.
34
:Richie: Is anybody doing anything about
it they can't buy a gun But like you said
35
:the founding fathers allowed search and
seizure but when have you ever heard of
36
:oh he's a felon over there Let's go check
and make sure he doesn't have a gun I
37
:don't know that it happens ever The only
time that the felon gets in trouble for
38
:having a gun is when he is caught in the
act of doing something and from someone
39
:who has sold a lot of guns you fill out
a form 44 73 and this is back in the day
40
:before iPads now it's all done on an iPad
and almost instant And You had to call in
41
:and they gave you the form and you went
over and you checked the boxes and Are
42
:you mentally defective Have you ever had
a misdemeanor Have you ever been a, oh
43
:gosh it's all kinds of questions citizens
Things like that and it's been a while
44
:since I've looked at one But and then
you made a phone call to the fDLE for
45
:Florida and you waited and they said all
right approved you wrote your approval
46
:number down Cool stamp it There's the
gun sale or conditional meaning Hey we've
47
:got a waiting period We need to look
deeper into this person we'll call you
48
:back We have three days before you can
release this firearm stamp it or denial
49
:Now they can never tell you why that was
the extent of what we knew when we were
50
:doing the 44 73 and the background checks.
51
:Dave: Yeah.
52
:Richie: So I guess to your question of
what can be done don't know But what I do
53
:know is nothing is being done to stop the
people that aren't supposed to have them
54
:from having them does that make sense Yeah
there's, and that's I would say that's
55
:a, our justice system in general right
Like the stat with Illinois 80 had prior
56
:arrest records they're still getting a
gun from somewhere and I know the question
57
:is if you do the gun show loophole or the
private sale loophole where I can walk up
58
:to you and say Hey I've got a gun You want
buy it 600 bucks here you go What how do
59
:I know you're a felon or not and it's I
don't feel that it is my job to police it
60
:as a private citizen like I I don't know
the right way there I don't think that you
61
:should stop that because if my dad wants
to sell me a gun is he not allowed to
62
:Dave: Well, Rich, so you're
saying I'm here in enforcement.
63
:So what does enforcement mean?
64
:Does that mean.
65
:Background checks.
66
:Does that mean if, like you're on, you're
in psychiatric counseling or you're
67
:taking psychiatric medications, then Yeah.
68
:Should, should guns be, locked up by maybe
a a gun dealer or local law enforcement.
69
:So what does enforcement mean to you
70
:Richie: It's a slippery slope because
I know that the nras Big thing and
71
:a lot of gun owners thing is if
we give an inch they take a mile
72
:Dave: Yeah
73
:Richie: And part of red flag
laws that are so scary is if you
74
:called the police department tomorrow
and Baker acted me guess what there goes
75
:my right to own a gun for a while and
that's just you doing it Now were you
76
:doing it because you think I'm a piece
of shit and You don't agree with me,
77
:Or do I really have a mental illness
78
:Josiah: is guilty until proven innocent.
79
:Richie: Exactly And so I think law
abiding gun owners are afraid that if we
80
:say 'cause I do agree that there could
be some tightening in certain areas.
81
:I don't know what that looks like I don't
know what that is because we've seen the
82
:government, we've seen all kinds of things
where it gets taken further and deeper
83
:every single time case in point like the
red flag deal somebody listening to this
84
:podcast could literally baker act me and
then I'm now no longer allowed to own
85
:a gun because I'm adjudicated mentally
defective which if I put no on the 44 73
86
:I'm now breaking a federal law I don't
know your answer and I don't have an
87
:answer for you I just know that it is a
extremely slippery slope and it can go
88
:really bad really quick for a good person
following the law I guess that's my answer
89
:Jerremy: Yeah, that was a great answer.
90
:You're also saying, and I heard you
say I meaning like you would be okay
91
:if it was structured the right way.
92
:If it was proposed the correct
way, you'd be all right for some
93
:additional enforcement of some kind.
94
:example, every year you have to
register your car, you gotta pay a
95
:registration fee, and that goes directly
to the state, the county, whoever.
96
:Would you be willing to do something
like that with a gun every year where
97
:you pay some X amount of dollars,
$20 to say, Hey, I still have it.
98
:I still own it.
99
:And that $20 goes to a mental health
organization or the Veteran's Affairs
100
:Act where we actually can pour into
the mental stability of our citizens.
101
:Richie: So this is where you May
disagree with me, but No, it is not a
102
:Josiah: law abiding yeah
103
:Richie: Exactly it is My second amendment
right to own those guns I don't have
104
:to tell you how many I have because the
criminals that have em illegally aren't
105
:gonna do that so that just defeats
the purpose and you're only penalizing
106
:the law abiding citizens it is not a
an amendment to own a vehicle that's
107
:a luxury so I would differ on that.
108
:I don't know because I again, it
is a very slippery slope I just
109
:spit balling shot in the dark here.
110
:Let's say you had a felony and
you can no longer own a gun and
111
:you, 'cause technically your
guns are halfway registered.
112
:When you fill out a 44 73, they put
the serial number down on it There is
113
:database that you can back on and see.
114
:Okay, Richie Swell bought that
gun now whether I have it anymore
115
:or Not, that's two different
things, but it is to my name.
116
:So if you commit a felony, maybe
I don't know, pretty intrusive.
117
:But number one, you have
to give up your guns.
118
:Number two, there should be annual
checks of do you have a gun?
119
:And that's just a shot in the dark.
120
:And I don't necessarily know that
I agree with it, but talk about
121
:enforcement, but you committed the felony.
122
:So, you know, I didn't commit the felony.
123
:I don't know.
124
:I really don't.
125
:there's not a perfect
answer to it 'cause sure.
126
:Do you know why I think
you don't know Richie?
127
:Why?
128
:'cause again, there is no way to
legislate evil out of this world.
129
:True.
130
:Josiah: And I think the flaw
in the question is how can
131
:we get this down to zero?
132
:Dave: I can say the craziest stuff, right?
133
:And yet there are fences on that, right?
134
:I can't libel you, I can't,
you know, I can't try to sell
135
:you, swamp here in Florida.
136
:You know, like all of those
things are illegal and yet
137
:technically they're free speech.
138
:You know, so like everything has a fence
as gun owners, as people who are like,
139
:this is my right, and I agree with you.
140
:What are those fences that you'd be okay
with that also helps, protect and the
141
:safety and maybe people who, who don't
own guns, you know, like what, what kind
142
:of fence would you be okay with, if any?
143
:Josiah: Yeah, I think he hit it
on the head with the enforcement
144
:of what we've already got, right?
145
:Because those are people who've
already shown a capacity, right?
146
:I think we need to tighten up on, again,
what he talked about, was it 80% people
147
:already had, offenses and a long sheet?
148
:how are we letting rap
sheets get that long?
149
:Now, again, I don't know enough
about, that, but how is somebody
150
:out there running around who has 15
arrests in the first place, right?
151
:That seems like a good place to start.
152
:To me.
153
:I agree.
154
:I'm totally against red flag
laws because again, that's just,
155
:too much of a slippery slope.
156
:It's guilty until proven innocent.
157
:And the other stuff that
we're talking about, like what
158
:Jerremy brought up, right?
159
:The $20, kind of re-report
everything every year, right?
160
:It's not about the cost of it
or even the hassle of reporting
161
:it, it's who's gonna do that?
162
:All your law abiding citizens are
gonna do the people you're not
163
:worried about going out and committing
one of these atrocities, right?
164
:Somebody who would do that.
165
:The likelihood of them actually
acquiescing to that requirement
166
:is probably pretty nil, right?
167
:So it's, you know, again, it's
this idea that we're going to just
168
:be able to legislate evil away.
169
:I think there are bigger root causes that
we could address than the guns themselves.
170
:Kind of like this
conversation started off.
171
:Yeah.
172
:You know, fatherlessness is a huge one.
173
:You know what is fueling
the fatherlessness epidemic
174
:in this country, right?
175
:That makes for a big swath of things
going off the rails with developing youth.
176
:Not having a father in the picture.
177
:That to me would have a much
more massive systemic impact
178
:Jerremy: mm-hmm.
179
:Josiah: On our culture as a whole
than again, clamping down access to
180
:an inanimate object that everybody
who's going to participate in those
181
:restrictions anyways are Already
proving themselves responsible.
182
:Dave: So this is what I'm hearing,
and correct me if I'm wrong that the
183
:laws we have now aren't either being
enforced or they're not working for
184
:you, or they could lead to more issues.
185
:And so we should have fewer of the laws
like red flag laws or less on that, and
186
:we should make sure felons don't own guns.
187
:Richie: Yeah.
188
:Josiah: On the spot?
189
:Yeah.
190
:I think that's a good starting point.
191
:Richie: Yeah.
192
:And to speak to the registration
and stuff between:
193
:there were over 92,000 firearms
confiscated without serial numbers.
194
:So registering 'em doesn't
do anything anyway.
195
:Yeah.
196
:You know?
197
:Mm-hmm.
198
:Whether that be a ghost
gun or it was filed off,
199
:Josiah: Sure,
200
:Richie: Filed Off.
201
:Yeah.
202
:Um, and so it is, it's one of those things
where you're damned if you do, damned
203
:if you don't, in a lot of aspects of it.
204
:And, Josiah said it perfectly, I think
there are other issues at play that the
205
:guns are getting their fingers pointed at.
206
:Like, why?
207
:Just redirecting for two seconds and
let me go off on my little tangent.
208
:Doctors kill 250,000 people
a year for malpractice.
209
:Jerremy: Mm-hmm.
210
:Richie: I haven't heard the
first let's get rid of a doctor.
211
:Josiah: and that's that consistency.
212
:Richie: And we're talking about, and I
know that I'm not this type of person,
213
:but I'm just gonna say facts here,
we're talking about 46,000 people a year
214
:Dave: Yeah, I hear you.
215
:But doctors are also licensed.
216
:And they can lose that license and
they require continuing education.
217
:Is it too much to say that if you're
a gun owner, you are licensed?
218
:Right.
219
:And you have to do continuing education.
220
:as another citizen, if you own a
weapon, I wanna make sure you are
221
:completely up on all the laws, that
you are a super citizen because you
222
:have a super responsibility with a gun.
223
:I wanna make sure that you understand
the laws and I wanna make sure that
224
:you know how to use that weapon.
225
:Is that too much to ask?
226
:Richie: So my question to you is,
has malpractice gone down with the
227
:continuing education and the licensing?
228
:Dave: I don't know, but I'm gonna guess
that there's a lot of crappy doctors
229
:out there that are no longer practicing.
230
:I mean, I can't prove the negative,
but I'm gonna say that's my,
231
:you know, like, that's my point.
232
:we have better doctors with those
contingencies than I would, you know,
233
:like if, if my doctor was not licensed
and you know, had had a bunch of issues
234
:and you know, like I wouldn't go to a
doctor who didn't go to medical school.
235
:I'm asking you to make sure that
everybody goes to a gun school.
236
:Is that okay?
237
:Richie: So if you want to hunt, you
have to go do a hunter safety course.
238
:Dave: Great,
239
:Richie: right?
240
:Mm-hmm.
241
:And that is required to be able
to hunt and get a hunting license.
242
:Jerremy: Yeah.
243
:Richie: I don't see an issue with,
if you're gonna buy a gun, you need
244
:to go through a gun safety course.
245
:I don't see an issue with that.
246
:I, I think that could only help.
247
:it does a number of things.
248
:It actually opens up job opportunity.
249
:It gives people that are professionals
in the industry or with firearms,
250
:you know, the opportunity to teach.
251
:Same with how it used to be to
get a concealed carry permit.
252
:You had to go through concealed
carry class, you had to take a
253
:test, and then you had to go to the
range with an instructor and fire.
254
:So it's kind of already there.
255
:I don't know how all states are.
256
:I know Florida used to be that way
to get your concealed, and I think
257
:even with the open carry to get a
concealed carry permit in Florida,
258
:you still have to go through that.
259
:I would not be opposed to that because
like hunters do it and they do it, you
260
:know, that's like a rite of passage for
the 13 to 14-year-old fixing to get his
261
:hunting license when he turns 16 or 17.
262
:So I don't see an issue with it.
263
:but with every bad apple, there's
gonna people that just sign off,
264
:collect the 30 bucks and move on.
265
:Josiah: And using the, the
doctor analogy again, to your
266
:point you said the CEUs right?
267
:And the licensing and all that
kind of stuff does make for better
268
:doctors than if we didn't have that.
269
:Right.
270
:What does that I'm, I'm saying I wouldn't,
271
:Dave: I wouldn't go to a doctor
who didn't go to medical school
272
:and didn't keep up on things.
273
:Josiah: absolutely.
274
:I wouldn't either.
275
:Yeah.
276
:But there are people who do.
277
:Sure.
278
:So my question was going to be, what
about all the people who are out there
279
:practicing medicine that aren't licensed?
280
:What do regulations like that do for them?
281
:To me that's kind of the
equivalent for mm-hmm.
282
:The criminal sector in
the gun conversation.
283
:What is legislating the good
people who are gonna participate
284
:do for the segment of society that
we're actually trying to impact?
285
:My question and I just to be really
clear here, I don't have an answer.
286
:Yeah.
287
:But I've not seen, or I've not seen
or heard of a piece of legislation
288
:that I'm like, oh my gosh, that
will fix the actual problem.
289
:Yeah.
290
:It's always the guns we're going after.
291
:It's never the people.
292
:Jerremy: Yeah.
293
:Only My whole topic and my whole
belief, my whole narrative is gonna come
294
:down to it's being generally at some
point sensationalized by our leaders
295
:or essentially lack of leadership.
296
:Alex: The Second Amendment isn't hunting
for them — it's the final check on power.
297
:Richie nods...
298
:but enforcement already fails everywhere.
299
:The firewall holds strong...
300
:while streets burn anyway.
