We Blame Guns But Is Fatherlessness Driving America’s Violence?
85% of inmates grew up without fathers. Jerremy Alexander Newsome and Dave Conley sit down with Josiah Graves to unpack how absent dads fuel violence. It’s not just guns – it’s heart issues in young men driving crime, poverty, and hate. They hit faith, family decline, and why open dialogue plus real accountability actually move the needle. Timestamps:
- (00:00) 85% of inmates fatherless – that’s the real core issue, not firearms
- (01:08) Human heart drives violence – guns are secondary to absent fathers
- (05:00) Faith shapes moral view on guns – beliefs matter more than policy
- (11:10) Traditional family collapse – direct cause of poverty, hate, crime
- (13:37) Open dialogue requires accountability – leadership fixes root problems
Connect:
Josiah Graves – Dads Ranch
Transcript
Policy stalls hard — so Jerremy ties violence straight to absent fathers.
2
:Crime follows the empty chair...
3
:while Dave presses on peacemakers.
4
:How does religion and guns fit together?
5
:Jerremy: Because what you
said earlier, fatherlessness.
6
:85% of individuals in prison are because
they do not have a dad in the household.
7
:That's the highest statistic that
we currently have, where it's like
8
:if you go to prison, it is probably
because you did not have a dad.
9
:Doesn't matter your race it generally
doesn't matter how much money you make.
10
:Did you have a dad?
11
:No, that's right.
12
:You're probably gonna go to jail.
13
:You're probably gonna go
to prison, most likely.
14
:Mm-hmm.
15
:And then both of you have also mentioned
this word that you are teaching, right?
16
:You're teaching your kids, you're
teaching people around you, you are having
17
:conversations, and you are educating
individuals on certain powerful topics.
18
:One thing that I definitely believe is
there is going to be a root problem.
19
:And that root problem doesn't
directly absolutely focus around guns.
20
:In fact, both Dave and myself, when we
started creating this topic, we're like,
21
:all right, man, let's talk gun control.
22
:And then really what it came down
to is like, all right, both me
23
:and Dave are super pro human.
24
:We're not really pro guns
or, con guns we're pro human.
25
:And it, it's like, it's the
human issue somewhere in here
26
:that's really the problem.
27
:Josiah: Mm-hmm.
28
:Jerremy: As you have mentioned,
Josiah and Richie also, like there,
29
:it's, the problem is you cannot
legislate evil out of the world.
30
:Can you decrease evil or can you decrease
frustration, anger, animosity, violence,
31
:which also can all stem from poverty?
32
:And I think ultimately my answer is, it
is possible to do that more than directly
33
:impact the negativity that guns create.
34
:Josiah: Yeah.
35
:Agreed.
36
:I totally agree.
37
:And the, I'm glad you said what you
said about, you know, the fatherless
38
:statistic and prison, right?
39
:And the first thing that came to
my mind was not just violence.
40
:how much violence would that, prevent, but
also what would that do for the economy?
41
:What if all of those people
were contributing productive
42
:members of society?
43
:Instead of in prison for
mistakes that they had made.
44
:Imagine that for a second.
45
:What would that do for us economically?
46
:What would that do for those
lower income communities?
47
:It might help them ratchet up a lot.
48
:Rising tide raises all ships.
49
:I think that would have way more positive
impacts than just reducing violence.
50
:I think it definitely would reduce
violence, but I think there would be a lot
51
:of other really incredible side effects if
we got to really the root of that issue.
52
:Jerremy: Yeah, man, I get it.
53
:I totally understand like that.
54
:But that's what's beautiful.
55
:And Dave and I are always smiling because
ultimately every single discussion that
56
:we have always comes back to that at
some point, is how do we make the heart
57
:of men, because the panel of US four are
the most dangerous creatures on earth.
58
:Uh, well, maybe not on earth,
but definitely in America.
59
:Like you guys mentioned serial killers.
60
:. Like 95%, 90% of serial
killers are white men, right?
61
:Mass school shootings, mostly white men.
62
:People that have murdered
extremely famous.
63
:Political figures or historical
figures, mostly white men.
64
:And there's a long, long list.
65
:But the general topic is it is men, right?
66
:And men are gonna control
and do most of the damage.
67
:And so ultimately, if, when we talk about
homelessness, when we talk about prison
68
:reform, when we've discussed guns, when
we've discussed financial freedom, when
69
:we've discussed the changes that we
need to make in this country in relation
70
:to education, it almost always comes
down to the heart of most young men
71
:and most countries is filled with anger
and frustration and annoyance and hate.
72
:And that at some point ultimately spills
over into this unproductive core group
73
:of a society that causes and creates
rape, that creates fatherless homes, that
74
:creates a population of other boys and
girls that are not loved, that are not
75
:looked out for, that are not cared for.
76
:And at some stage, the educational
component of this country has
77
:to come up and say, why are all
the people that continually have
78
:97% of the impact negatively?
79
:How do we change that
from a core systemic way?
80
:Because we're always trying to pick
apart the small little things that.
81
:End up being part of the
formula, but we never start
82
:with the actual formula, right?
83
:We try to start with the equal sign, we
always go to that side of the formula
84
:versus the beginning part of the formula.
85
:Josiah: Right.
86
:I mean, as you're talking
about that I think it's a very
87
:important thing to point out.
88
:And this crossed my mind the other day
as I was preparing for this as well,
89
:you know what really would solve the
problem a hundred percent is if everybody
90
:accepted Jesus as their Lord and Savior.
91
:because someone who has Jesus, is
not going to commit a mass shooting.
92
:But those same people who want us to
take all the guns away so there are
93
:no more gun violence, they wouldn't
be okay with us requiring that.
94
:You see what I'm saying?
95
:Mm-hmm.
96
:That really would solve the problem.
97
:Dave: So I love that you said that.
98
:And I want, I wanna hear a little bit
more about that because Richie's as you
99
:both speak about your faith and Jesus
is front and center with your family,
100
:your fun, your work, you know, and Jesus
commanded Peter to put the sword away.
101
:Our peacemakers are
called children of God.
102
:We turn the other cheek.
103
:The gospels are about
love, even for our enemies.
104
:What are moral questions, perhaps
for someone who isn't a follower
105
:that could learn from your journey?
106
:Do followers of God have to
dig deeper when it comes to the
107
:morality around faith and firearms?
108
:Josiah: Man, that is, that is so good.
109
:One thing immediately comes to
mind, when people quote scripture,
110
:they take things outta context.
111
:And not saying that you're, that's
your intention here, but people
112
:quote that, you know, told Peter
to put the sword away many times.
113
:Right.
114
:What was the context of that situation?
115
:Dave: Jesus was, uh, being dragged off
to the cross and Peter had, uh, sliced
116
:the ear of, uh, Malachi, I believe.
117
:And he's like, no, no.
118
:Put that sword away.
119
:Uh, that's right.
120
:He healed the ear and,
uh, that's the context
121
:' Josiah: cause so Jesus knew that
if he laid waste to that leg of
122
:Roman soldiers, then what he came
to do was not going to be fulfilled.
123
:So in the context of that situation,
in that moment, the reason he told
124
:Peter to put the sword away was
because what needed to happen was he
125
:needed to be taken by those Romans to
ultimately be crucified for our sins.
126
:So that's the context of that situation.
127
:There's also another place
in the Bible where God told
128
:Saul and the army of Israel.
129
:To slay every single amalekite and not
even leave any of their animals alive.
130
:People tend to leave stuff
like that out, right?
131
:There definitely are situations
where or here you go, leave
132
:the human element out of it.
133
:The flood, the human race had gotten so
corrupted and not just corrupted with
134
:evil, but corrupted genetically, right?
135
:You had the nephilim the watchers,
having babies with human people, right?
136
:Literally corrupting God's creation.
137
:It had gotten so bad that the only
family left on earth that was not
138
:touched by that corruption was Noah
and his family, and what did God do?
139
:He wiped the entire earth out.
140
:He killed everybody else, right?
141
:So there are situations where
evil absolutely needs to be met.
142
:With that kind of force, God has
shown us that himself, right?
143
:Now, he always gives people
a chance to repent, right?
144
:But if someone smashes in my door in the
middle of the night, we're past that.
145
:We're past repentance, right?
146
:'cause now my life and my
family's life is in danger, right?
147
:You know, I think, you know, as,
as a, as a Christian, as a Bible
148
:believer, as a Jesus follower, is
it hard to reconcile that for me?
149
:No, because It is a very clear
line in my situation that I told
150
:you about at the beginning, I
didn't jump straight into action.
151
:Jerremy: Mm-hmm.
152
:Josiah: But I was ready
to, if I needed to.
153
:Right.
154
:And the situation deescalated.
155
:So is that hard to reconcile for us?
156
:No, because again, that
is a very clear line.
157
:But if my family, my kids, my wife,
myself, or even someone around me
158
:that I don't know that I have the
power to help is in the mix, I
159
:think that's gonna be a very obvious
decision, you know, at that moment.
160
:And Rich, I'll let you add to that.
161
:Richie: I don't know that
I can, to be very honest.
162
:That was very well said.
163
:It was, um, you know, I operate off of,
treat people how you want to be treated.
164
:Be a good person, do the right thing.
165
:And, one of the 10
commandments do not kill.
166
:I'm not gonna kill anybody unless
it is absolutely necessary.
167
:I pray that I never
have to pull my pistol.
168
:Like this is something that I hear a
lot in podcasts and other things you
169
:hear and see is like, you know, some of
these gun owners, they're just waiting
170
:to pull their pistol and have to use it.
171
:I would say those are the fake ones.
172
:Jerremy: Yeah.
173
:Richie: Like the 90, probably
majority of most gun owners.
174
:And you can know this is true because
like military especially like real
175
:combat veterans don't speak on their like
actual, what they went through a lot.
176
:A lot of 'em don't,
especially when it was bad.
177
:And a lot of veterans that I've
spoke to, they don't want to ever
178
:have to use their firearm again.
179
:They're not just blood sucking
military guys that are robots trained
180
:to kill like they killed because
they had to because it was wartime.
181
:And I look at it from that standpoint
of I hope I never have to use my
182
:firearm in that capacity ever.
183
:I don't even want to pull it.
184
:But I am prepared if I have to
because if I have to get to that
185
:point, it's protection of myself.
186
:It is protection of my family
or it is protecting someone
187
:that cannot protect themselves.
188
:Hmm.
189
:Josiah: By the way, if you go back
to the original Hebrew on the 10
190
:Commandments, it's not, thou shalt
not kill, it's thou shalt not murder.
191
:Richie: Murder.
192
:Josiah: There is a difference.
193
:Richie: Yeah.
194
:Big difference.
195
:So, and then something that before I
had to use the restroom, something that
196
:y'all were talking about was fatherless.
197
:So 1970, approximately 85%.
198
:Of children lived with a two
parent household,:
199
:And I didn't drill down demographics.
200
:I just, just straight United States.
201
:Just quick Google search.
202
:And I think that has a lot to do with it.
203
:And I think it's media based on some, like
we are tearing down the family household.
204
:And I think that is a lot of
problems, not just firearm related.
205
:I just overall, I think there is a
ton of issues that the traditional
206
:family is almost being looked at as
like a, that's not right anymore.
207
:And I think that causes a lot of problems.
208
:And I don't remember, I may, I should
probably shouldn't even say it, but
209
:there was a Russian or German guy a long
time ago, sixties maybe, that talked if
210
:I was to tear down the United States.
211
:And he basically wrote the
playbook of how he would do it and
212
:it's all playing out right now.
213
:Josiah: Yep.
214
:Richie: And I don't remember names and
I don't remember exactly what he said.
215
:I just remember hearing it
one time and I was like, holy
216
:crap, that is wildly accurate.
217
:And so that tells me, are we.
218
:As a country, as a bigger whatever, are
we purposely trying to make everything
219
:decisive to start continually dividing
the people, you know, and so that
220
:everybody's fighting with everyone
and it, it's crazy to me that we've
221
:gotten this decisive with stuff.
222
:Yeah, you can't have a conversation if you
didn't vote for the same party anymore.
223
:Right.
224
:Jerremy: Yeah.
225
:Richie: and I still have buddies that
are clearly I'm on the right and I have
226
:buddies on the left, and I can still
have conversations with them, thankfully.
227
:But then I also have friends that I
have genuinely lost that we were very
228
:close, that I'm like you can't have
a conversation with 'em because the
229
:minute you say something different,
you're a racist, you're a bigot.
230
:You know, you don't care
about this group of people.
231
:You don't care about that group of
people, and I don't talk to 'em anymore.
232
:Jerremy: Yeah, and I think what
you mentioned Richie earlier was,
233
:is someone doing this on purpose?
234
:And I don't know if the answer to that
is yes, but what I can say is we do
235
:not truly have a lot of leadership that
does exactly what you mentioned, which
236
:is let's all have a communication.
237
:Right.
238
:Let's make and have some really
beautiful open dialogue also, because
239
:it's not really taught in school, right?
240
:You have one orator essentially that
presents on a topic, and this is
241
:truth and do not argue with me, right?
242
:I gave you your answers on your
quiz or your test, and this is
243
:the right way or the wrong way.
244
:And so we're judging a lot of people early
on by what they're doing or what they're
245
:not doing based on one person's opinion.
246
:And that kind of like trickles
down the entire system.
247
:Where again, right now, we all
know that we have President Trump,
248
:and we would all agree that he's
more divisive than not, right?
249
:He's not like, Hey, everyone
should be hanging out and talking
250
:and having a good time and we
should be growing together, right?
251
:He's not really that direction.
252
:Uh, he instantly blamed a certain
political group, uh, after Charlie
253
:Kirk's death, which I thought was, uh,
a misappropriation of time and space for
254
:what he could have done a lot better.
255
:But ultimately for me, one thing that
I definitely agree with all of you on,
256
:and I really have always is we do need
to have more ability of conversation
257
:from both sides so that we can learn and
people have to start practicing that.
258
:I mean, not only are we practicing
it right now, but what we're gonna
259
:continue to do is have conversations
with people that go, listen, let's
260
:agree to disagree, but let's also
find out where I might be incorrect.
261
:Where you might be incorrect.
262
:And let's see if there's any bridge
that can be formulated between the two
263
:so that we both can either merge to a
middle ground or we can at least agree
264
:with each other and still be friends,
still be good networks, still be good
265
:business partners, and start moving
on to something bigger and better
266
:and more prosperous for the nation.
267
:That's one thing that I really
feel like our leadership
268
:has done a very poor job of,
269
:Richie: And something to speak on that
I think part of that problem to why a
270
:lot of people can't have conversations
anymore is they are fed the information
271
:that their side is, whether it's right
or wrong, and that's what they believe.
272
:And it is so hard to find one
accountability to the truth, and you don't
273
:know what's real and what's not, because
there's so much information out there,
274
:there's so much disinformation out there.
275
:Sometimes it's real, sometimes it's not.
276
:Well, if you're on the side of
you believe the disinformation and
277
:you don't know any better because,
so you're gonna argue that point.
278
:And same on the other side.
279
:You may be on the side of the truth.
280
:You may not know it, it was just
the information you were given.
281
:And so there's so little accountability to
getting the actual information out there.
282
:Yeah.
283
:That is real.
284
:Using the Charlie Kirk, how
many conspiracies have come
285
:out since he's been killed?
286
:Jerremy: Already, like stuff,
287
:Richie: oh my gosh.
288
:Jerremy: familiar with.
289
:Richie: Yeah.
290
:Like my wife went down the
rabbit hole and I finally just
291
:had to tell her, please stop.
292
:I don't know what's real and what's
not, but I know this is ridiculous
293
:and we need better accountability.
294
:And I think that starts
with the media, honestly.
295
:Yeah.
296
:Uh, if you're gonna put something
out there and it's fake, there
297
:should be consequences for it.
298
:That's what I think.
299
:And call it free speech,
call it whatever you want.
300
:But at a certain point you're
just a propaganda tool.
301
:And that's part of the problem.
302
:Jerremy: Yeah.
303
:Well, this'll be, um, maybe an overarching
point that actually does circle back,
304
:Dave to a previous discussion that we had.
305
:You know, we gentlemen went in depth on
prison reform and we talked to judges,
306
:we talked to prison inmates, we talked
to police officers, we talked to ex felon
307
:or current felons that are out of prison.
308
:We had some really deep discussions
on it, and that was a word that was
309
:used relatively often accountability.
310
:And one of the groups of people that
aren't really held accountable, that does
311
:have a big trickle down effect is judges.
312
:Hmm.
313
:When a judge says, alright,
cool, you didn't kill somebody,
314
:and they actually did.
315
:Or because a judge can override a
jury, I'm sure you guys all know this.
316
:Mm-hmm.
317
:Right.
318
:Number one.
319
:But number two is like you guys
mentioned, someone having a rap
320
:sheet of 14, 15 arrests mm-hmm.
321
:And going on killing someone else.
322
:how come no one's being held
accountable to any of these standards?
323
:Back to the whole felon piece.
324
:Like, okay, you start getting too
many arrests and you're still getting
325
:a gun illegally and you get caught
and they go back on the streets a
326
:short period of time afterwards.
327
:So there is, I love the word
accountability and I do believe
328
:that there is a big metric of
that missing in this country.
329
:Accountability from a
lot of different sides.
330
:'Cause you're, you're both right.
331
:you have free speech and then you
have blatantly lying that conjures
332
:up fear that conjures up riots.
333
:Right?
334
:There are certain speeches and terms of
speech that cannot be used openly and
335
:publicly And, hate speech is one of them.
336
:Mm-hmm.
337
:I think the accountability piece
is missing and I don't know exactly
338
:where that stems from or exactly
what that ultimate fix looks like,
339
:but there's gonna be certain, pegs
in the circle board of this country
340
:that is missing accountability.
341
:And I think the more that we as a
nation just talk about that openly.
342
:And discuss that openly and have these
convictions where it's like, this is a
343
:real big problem and we have to start
actually addressing it and working
344
:on creating a good solution for it,
rather than just arguing about it.
345
:There are people that can start
making these really powerful choices
346
:that actually create not only
accountability, but true change as well.
347
:Mm-hmm.
348
:Alex: Media wedges neighbors apart
for profit — everyone sees it.
349
:Division pays too well.
350
:Jerremy flips though
to ten-second truths...
351
:why own, why carry, no filter.
