Immigration’s $8.9 Trillion Reality—Why Politics Keeps Failing America
After 100+ deep dives, Jerremy and Dave cut through the confusion: immigration adds $8.9 trillion to GDP yet the system is choked by bureaucracy, a 4-million-case backlog, and the whiplash of presidential power shifts. From Dave’s personal evolution on the issue to the story of a Florida accident shaped by four administrations’ conflicting rules, this episode shows how immigration policy is less about people—and more about broken governance.
Timestamps:
(00:00) 100+ Episodes Later: What We’ve Learned
(00:56) How Immigration Changed Our Minds
(02:01) The $8.9 Trillion Impact—Numbers That Matter
(04:03) Why Paperwork, Lawyers, and Waitlists Keep Failing
(06:07) Presidential Whiplash: Four Administrations, One Case
(12:03) Backlogs, Downturns, and the Scarcity Mindset
📢 Solving America’s Problems Podcast – Real Solutions For Real Issues
Transcript
Dave, we're bringing the heat.
2
:Oh my goodness.
3
:You know what I'm excited about, man?
4
:Mo.
5
:Tons of things.
6
:One of them being we're over 100
episodes in and now we get to discuss
7
:and talk about Immigration Nation.
8
:What did we learn?
9
:Which is so far been
everyone's favorite, right?
10
:Once we go through something, we deep
dive, we have interviews, discussions,
11
:chats, breakthroughs, monumental
awakenings, paradigm shifts, and then we
12
:wrap it all together on what do we learn,
and that's where we're at right now.
13
:Dave: This has also
been our longest series.
14
:Like I have learned all the
different topics we've done.
15
:I mean, I've loved every
single one of them.
16
:And you were like, let's do immigration.
17
:I went like, oh, okay.
18
:How are we gonna approach this?
19
:That's a hot topic.
20
:Let's do it.
21
:And in all the topics,
22
:school shootings and
23
:Jerremy: Actually, I think you
said, oh, no one's gonna get
24
:offended by anything we discussed,
then it's gonna be perfectly fine.
25
:Dave: this has been fun.
26
:And I feel changed from it.
27
:So I think this is, what did we learn?
28
:I learned a lot.
29
:Jerremy: That's cool.
30
:So for a moment, when you
say you felt change tell me
31
:a little bit more about that.
32
:What does that mean, or how
does that resonate with you and
33
:Where do you feel that shift?
34
:Dave: I think coming into this, I came
in with a certain amount of, yeah.
35
:Illegal immigration, bad.
36
:Yeah.
37
:I'm okay with deportations, but you know,
how it's happening now is just barbaric.
38
:And immigrants, you
know, is it really good?
39
:You know, like, immigration
very confused, right?
40
:It's like, uh, immigration is good.
41
:And I was sort of a mixed bag on it.
42
:But also growing up in a very diverse,
immigrant rich world, it's like, I
43
:don't have anything against this.
44
:I just saw it as a problem.
45
:Yet another American
problem is immigration.
46
:And then really hearing, well,
it's a problem of our own
47
:making like so many things.
48
:It's a problem of our political
class, and how that's failing us.
49
:It's.
50
:A problem of perception
more than anything.
51
:And I came out with a couple of
things that I think really shifted me,
52
:which was, this is such an economic
problem in so many different ways
53
:and can be solved economically.
54
:When we take the word illegal out of
this discussion and put in economic
55
:prosperity and drive this through what
everybody's doing, which is they're
56
:coming here, they're working, they're
contributing to society, and let's take
57
:the illegal legal thing out of this.
58
:Let's simplify this.
59
:Let's make this about great
jobs and great families.
60
:English is really important.
61
:That came up so many times.
62
:It almost sounded a little bit, I
don't know if racist is the right word,
63
:it sounded a little bit like Oggie.
64
:But then when you talk to a bunch
of immigrants and second and third
65
:generation immigrants, they're
like, oh no, English was clutch.
66
:And America is so good about
immigration integration.
67
:Wow.
68
:I'll say that five times.
69
:And the big key thing for
everyone we talked to was like,
70
:oh, English was the thing.
71
:Like my parents, they wouldn't allow
us to speak any other language.
72
:And in a way I thought
about like, my father.
73
:My father came from the south,
and when he moved to Washington
74
:DC he forced his accent out.
75
:And because if you're from the
south and you have an accent, you're
76
:immediately thought of as stupid.
77
:And I think same, same in this world,
which is if you don't have command of the
78
:English language, you're seen as foreign.
79
:Even if you've been here 40 years,
you know, even if you've lived here
80
:longer than you have anywhere else, if
you don't have command of the English
81
:language, then you're seen as, as other,
as less than or from somewhere else.
82
:And no matter what you look like,
where you come from, what you do, but
83
:if you have command of the English
language, it's like, oh, welcome.
84
:So that was a couple of things for me.
85
:What was, what are some,
some highlights for you?
86
:Jerremy: Highlights, number one, having
just really good conversations with
87
:people that, number one, really care
about the topic, but also number two,
88
:they have a lot of information about it.
89
:We
90
:had tons of really unique characters in
this go around with different opinions.
91
:We got a nice little fight.
92
:We got left, we got right, we got some
excitement there, which I really enjoyed.
93
:And also we're coming up with just some
general Hey, this is what is working.
94
:This is what can work.
95
:This is what should work.
96
:This is a problem.
97
:AKA paperwork, lawyers fees,
98
:lines, and here's some solutions.
99
:And they were pretty fast.
100
:Like we had a lot of really great, let's
implement this as quick as possible.
101
:'cause it really wouldn't be that
challenging, wouldn't be that hard.
102
:And one of the things I never really sat
103
:down and really looked at or
studied probably would be that how
104
:immigration does drive us economic
105
:growth, right?
106
:Adding 8.9
107
:trillion to the gross domestic
product and filling vital labor gaps.
108
:I think me just really seeing that from
a, how much is the impact maybe, or
109
:for whatever particular reason, I just
didn't notice or know how large it would
110
:be or should be, or could be or was.
111
:And to see a, 8.9
112
:trillion if our annual gross
domestic has called 25,
113
:so we're at 30%.
114
:That's massive.
115
:And then we had a lot of distinction
in different types of immigrants
116
:and learning about their battles
and their choices, right?
117
:We had people that do not
live here, that just work
118
:here, that still can't get citizenship
that really want to, but they live in the
119
:us.
120
:We have people that don't work here
at all that do wanna come here.
121
:And they have a hard time.
122
:We have people that come here illegally
and then they get a job, somehow get paid
123
:in cash and can't get, become a citizen.
124
:And then we have people that are like,
oh, you have a bunch of money come on in.
125
:I think all of our listeners know my
ultimate objective of this entire podcast
126
:and this entire process is to just
really have a great grasp on not only
127
:the problems, but most importantly the
utions as I run for President:
128
:And I really believe that there
should be and could be a more focused
129
:approach on individual government
sections articles, processes that
130
:do not rely on one sole individual,
which to date has been an old white
131
:man dictating how immigration happens.
132
:And that's what's been.
133
:Forever obviously, right?
134
:You have the deporter in chief, the
one non-white old man, but still
135
:everything rested on his shoulders
and was kicking people out left
136
:and right, and somehow the media
portrayed him as the coolest guy ever.
137
:Nicest, kindest human being
of all time, which is cool.
138
:That's probably a whole other subject,
but that's the thing I learned, man.
139
:I do not believe in my heart of hearts
that the immigration decisions should
140
:rest, which where they do now really
in the lap of one person, which is the
141
:president, and that just seems like a
little too much immediate divisive power
142
:to
143
:me.
144
:Dave: there is a news story that's
making the rounds right now, actually,
145
:and it came out of some tragedy here
in Florida where I'll just, I'll use
146
:the language of, the news people.
147
:An illegal alien who was driving
a tractor trailer, made an illegal
148
:U-turn and killed three people and
149
:Jerremy: And they are
150
:Dave: Losing their, losing their
151
:minds.
152
:Jerremy: I'm trying to
think of a good verb.
153
:Losing their minds.
154
:Dave: Guy comes over from I
think he's Indian national
155
:uh, quote unquote illegally.
156
:I don't even know how, he
came into the United States.
157
:He got some sort of status under
Obama and in California he qualified
158
:for a commercial driver's license.
159
:Okay, fine.
160
:And then Trump comes in changes, it
puts him on deportation like quick
161
:deportation started that process.
162
:Biden comes in and this guy applies
for amnesty and is granted it.
163
:Except the deportation
law was still in place.
164
:And then the Trump administration
comes back in and says, this
165
:guy couldn't speak English.
166
:We've already changed.
167
:You know, we did an executive
order on that, on English language.
168
:And he can't even identify, road signs.
169
:So I heard all of this and I went,
okay, this actually typifies exactly,
170
:I mean, this is exactly the issue,
which is this guy for nine years has,
171
:been wrapped around the axle from one
administration to the next administration,
172
:to the next administration, to the
current administration, four different
173
:administrations, and in nine years.
174
:And this guy has been told.
175
:he got a commercial driver's license,
and he killed a bunch of people.
176
:Now, here's the thing, if we took the
fact out of this that he was quote
177
:unquote illegal, the real problem
here is the state of California.
178
:Like, who is handing out
commercial driver's licenses?
179
:Somebody you can't drive.
180
:I mean, that's what it gets down to it.
181
:The legal illegal thing is sort of
irrelevant, except it's telling me
182
:that this cannot be with one person.
183
:Like, we need to actually change the laws.
184
:I don't understand any of this.
185
:Right?
186
:Like I, when it gets down to it,
our political class has failed us.
187
:My question is why, you know,
like when we talk to Melissa.
188
:She was like, look, this is bonkers.
189
:You know, like I'm printing things
out and they're scanning them in
190
:and I'm faxing, you know, like it
was outta the eighties, and the
191
:laws haven't changed much since 86.
192
:And she said the laws that are
there are basically either special
193
:interest or a patchwork of stuff
that was valid 50 years ago.
194
:But you know, now in the 21st
century, it makes zero sense.
195
:So it's like, why is it in the best
interest of our legislature to do nothing?
196
:That's the part where I don't get it.
197
:I dunno, is it the same thing with
healthcare and all the other things
198
:that actually matter to people is like,
ah, they're not getting paid to do it.
199
:Nobody's paying our legislatures.
200
:Like they, they don't.
201
:They're not being paid enough
money by some weird special
202
:interest to do something.
203
:If this actually had something to
do with national security and just
204
:being sponsored by some other country,
it'd probably be done in 15 minutes.
205
:Right?
206
:Jerremy: It would be,
that's exactly correct.
207
:And that could be a solution right there.
208
:Hey, if you would've come here in this
country your country needs to pay for it.
209
:Dave: All
210
:Jerremy: All you need
211
:to do is have a check written by your
country and you can come right on
212
:over.
213
:But I think
214
:that's
215
:Dave: Let's talk a little
bit about the economic stuff.
216
:Like you mentioned trillions of dollars.
217
:I still can't even imagine
what a trillion dollars is.
218
:It's a lot, and then I also think
about how gummed up this process
219
:is 4 million pending court cases.
220
:Is it, what's the phrase?
221
:It's, uh, justice delayed Is
justice denied 4 million cases.
222
:That's ridiculous.
223
:people are going to be in these
situations for decades, and in the
224
:meantime, they're gonna have families,
they're gonna establish themselves,
225
:and then at the end of this process,
they're gonna actually show up to
226
:some sort of court case and somebody's
gonna throw 'em outta the country.
227
:I think what I'm, I.
228
:Our big, fight that we had, a lot of
it was economic based, you know, like
229
:immigrants are taking our jobs and we've
dispelled that in fact, one of the things
230
:that we talked about with Melissa was
it's like, we also need to change the Visa
231
:program where, yeah, you can get a PhD in
mathematics here, but if you need somebody
232
:to turn a wrench or to sell something
or to start a business, good luck.
233
:They're never gonna get into the country.
234
:I think my question to you is, what
happens when there's an economic
235
:downturn in the United States?
236
:Because there is going to be,
like it's not always up, but what
237
:happens when things go down and when
people get into a scarcity mindset,
238
:when there is competition for
jobs, do you think that will turn.
239
:Even uglier for immigrants,
240
:Jerremy: Oh yeah.
241
:I can't have someone say they took our
jobs without thinking about the South
242
:Park episode because they did that
243
:two decades ago.
244
:They took her and they just kept
going and going and it's really
245
:this fallacy I shouldn't say
it's a fallacy, it's a mindset.
246
:It's a belief.
247
:My opinion, I live more and what
I think is an abundance mindset.
248
:And then you have other people that are
gonna live in more of a scarcity mindset.
249
:And the scarcity mindset is
there'll never be enough jobs.
250
:And we have a limited amount and we're
251
:gonna run out.
252
:But the thought process there
is if you study more history and
253
:you talk about the industrial
revolution changes all jobs, right?
254
:Like in the 1890s, 99% of
every job that existed was
255
:agrarian.
256
:Meaning it had something to do with food
or land, or growing something, right?
257
:It was agricultural based, 99%.
258
:And so now today, it's less
259
:than 1%.
260
:So no one's growing
261
:shit, no one cares, right?
262
:We got seven
263
:farmers on
264
:this
265
:Dave: I think one of 'em
is Bill Gates, right?
266
:Doesn't he own like a
267
:Yeah.
268
:Tons of
269
:Jerremy: Bill Gates is the best
farmer, and you're correct.
270
:So less than 1% is agrarian,
and now we're all doing
271
:it stuff.
272
:Okay?
273
:So AI comes, immigrants come,
all these jobs get displaced,
274
:taken, removed, and changed.
275
:What is the entire world gonna do?
276
:And the answer is we're going to have to
adapt to something we always will, right?
277
:Necessity is the mother of invention.
278
:When humans sit around with
like, how do I make money?
279
:And that thought comes in
your mind every single day,
280
:you're gonna come up with ways.
281
:And that's one of the reasons
that podcasts blew up.
282
:And I would say in the two thousands
for sure, but definitely:
283
:20 like COVID started happening.
284
:Everyone's oh yeah, let's do podcasts.
285
:And I know seven people personally.
286
:I'm one of them that had a podcast during
that time that exploded because it just
287
:happened to be everyone was listening
to podcasts and the good ones took off.
288
:Alright, that's an example of, hey, let's
pick a random person that I know named
289
:Greg was making $8,000 a year start a
podcast, and because of podcasting and
290
:three businesses that he could spend
more time, energy, and effort on, took
291
:his income from 80,000 to 300,000.
292
:Now he's employing more people.
293
:He's paying more taxes.
294
:All the things happened, all because
of podcasting he literally quit his
295
:job as a police officer and started
podcasting and building a business.
296
:Now he transformed what he did.
297
:Humans will do that.
298
:Alex: Personal shifts unpacked,
economic truths revealed—but
299
:what if scarcity’s just a myth?
300
:Next, we dive into the math proving
America’s limitless potential.