Immigration Unveiled: The Hidden Layers of America's Crisis
Immigration is more than a headline—it’s a complex web of economics, demographics, and security. In this episode, hosts Jerremy and Dave dive into the hidden layers of America’s immigration crisis, from LA’s recent raids to historical policies that still shape today’s debates. Discover the untold stories and rigorous research behind their bold solutions, setting the stage for a series that promises fresh perspectives on a polarized issue.
Timestamps:
- (00:00) Introduction: Setting the Stage for America's Immigration Crisis
- (00:28) Current State: Unpacking the 3.7 Million Pending Court Cases
- (01:04) Economic Impact: How Immigrants Add $8.9 Trillion to GDP
- (04:21) Historical Context: From Colonial Biases to Modern Policies
- (07:35) Personal Perspectives: Hosts Share Their Immigration Stories
- (08:48) Political Stances: Trump, Obama, and the Immigration Debate
📢 Solving America’s Problems Podcast – Real Solutions For Real Issues
Transcript
Dave Conley, we're gonna go behind the scenes for
2
:solving America's problems.
3
:Dave: Yeah.
4
:Jerremy: To look a little
bit into how we are going to.
5
:Potentially the most
complex subject to date.
6
:Dave: Mm-hmm.
7
:Jerremy: With so many different thesises
and one that we are also not directly
8
:impacted by, nor have we been a part of,
nor have we could have been a part of.
9
:And that's immigration.
10
:Mm-hmm.
11
:We're gonna be discussing it,
talking about it, diving into it.
12
:But these episodes really stem
from the recent episode that we had
13
:catching everyone up on the current
state of affairs of the world.
14
:And one of those big issues was ice.
15
:And of course the huge LA raids and riots
that occurred over the immigration thesis.
16
:That's happening right now.
17
:And what we do know is the United States
Immigration System is experiencing
18
:unprecedented strain with over 3.7
19
:million, so almost 4
million pending court cases.
20
:And a president who is
extremely big on border control.
21
:That coupled with one of the things
I think a lot of people probably
22
:overlook or maybe overlook, I'm not
right the exact term, but immigrants
23
:definitely add a humongous portion
to our gross domestic product.
24
:8.9,
25
:not million, not billion trillion to the
top line of the GDP of America, Dave.
26
:So now we're talking balancing the
humanitarian point of it, balancing the
27
:actual balance sheet part of it, and just
discussing the humanistic standpoint.
28
:That is gonna be immigration.
29
:This is gonna be a big one for us to
cover, and it's gonna be a multifaceted
30
:multier episode that people are gonna
really absolutely fall in love with.
31
:Dave: I think this one's an easy one
to say, look, this is super polarized.
32
:Can we back up from this and
be like, okay, you know, like
33
:there's a lot of opinions.
34
:There's a lot of data, there's
a lot of, you know, like people
35
:who are dug in on both sides.
36
:And it's, I think it's really important
when we're looking at the problems.
37
:One is, hey, nobody's looking
at immigration saying,
38
:Hey, this is working great.
39
:Mm-hmm.
40
:And this is also not one of those
things where it's solved with
41
:executive orders and deportations.
42
:It's solved with like real
legislation, real practices, real
43
:things that we don't talk about.
44
:And also just understanding it
from those three key components.
45
:Like there's a huge
economic piece of this.
46
:There's also like a demographic piece
of this, you know, like we're not making
47
:enough babies in the United States and
we, you know, a society's only going
48
:to survive if it has enough, you know,
young people supporting the old people.
49
:Unlike like Japan, which has
been, cratering or China or
50
:You know, like these are
countries in crisis because they
51
:don't have enough young people.
52
:So we, we need to have it.
53
:And also the talent that comes on board,
you know, all of the stem folks that
54
:come over both, you know, documented,
under documented, that's the thing.
55
:And then balancing the
security aspect of it.
56
:This, which is really important.
57
:It's like if somebody's coming in, we
just wanna know who you are, right?
58
:Mm-hmm.
59
:And like, you know, so if we can really
kind of tease these things apart.
60
:A, pour some water on the rhetoric and
be like, okay, now we understand what the
61
:problems are and now onto the solutions.
62
:Jerremy: Yeah.
63
:So tell people a little bit about,
as you started building kind of the
64
:framework for myself and yourself on
not only research, but conversations
65
:that we're gonna have with some amazing,
incredible people in the future.
66
:How did you start and how did
you build the framework around
67
:this incredibly polarizing topic?
68
:Dave: Well, I think, I mean, this
goes back to a little bit of behind
69
:the scenes, you know, before we start
any of these topics, whether it's
70
:homelessness or debt or school or
safety, any of these things, what we
71
:start with is a whole lot of research.
72
:So like, what's going on out there?
73
:Because I don't know,
you're not an expert.
74
:I'm not an expert.
75
:You know, there's a few things that we are
expert in, but it's none of these topics.
76
:So, for instance, with immigration
we're staring at like a 14 page brief
77
:that I put together, and it covers as
many things as that I could think of.
78
:It's the key statistics,
it's the history of this.
79
:I mean, I didn't understand
the history of immigration.
80
:Like it goes back to before
there was a country and it's been
81
:poked at, you know, like
every 10 or 20 years.
82
:And, and we keep on poking at it, but
it goes, it, you know, like there's a
83
:huge foundation in the United States.
84
:Like we, you know, like
what was this all about?
85
:So yep.
86
:This huge historical context and
then sort of like the recent history,
87
:basically like the last 25 years,
what have the president's done?
88
:Mm-hmm.
89
:What are, you know, what are the
major legislation, if any, you
90
:know, like what, what has been
like, the big, big pieces with that.
91
:Then overall, what the problem is,
and that's like the core of it.
92
:Like what is the problem that
we're actually looking at?
93
:And then what are the solutions, not
just the ones that are proposed, but
94
:the solutions that have been tried
sometimes in the United States, like
95
:we do have some things that are working
right now, which surprised me, but
96
:also what are other countries doing?
97
:Like, like there are so many countries
that are struggling with immigration and
98
:there's a lot of experiments out there.
99
:I think, you know, we think that
we have to reinvent the wheel
100
:over and over and over again, and
that's just, that is not the case.
101
:But we're also looking at a
system that nobody is saying,
102
:Hey, this is, this is working.
103
:So it's like, okay, what does
work and can we build on that?
104
:Definitely also looking at what the
controversies are, what the divides
105
:are, what are the things where there
is like a lot of energy, like border
106
:walls or the dreamers or asylum
seekers, sanctuary cities, all of that.
107
:So like where, where is there like, like
this, where is there energy around things?
108
:And then also understanding what
people don't know about this.
109
:You know, like what are the, what
are sort of like the mysteries
110
:of this that people don't like?
111
:You know, one of my
favorite ones, uh, was that.
112
:That most undocumented or, you know,
illegal aliens, undocumented, however
113
:you wanna describe people who are, are
overstaying visas or coming into the
114
:nation without, you know, without a
visa or without any kind of information.
115
:Four outta five of those folks
have lived here for over 10 years.
116
:These people are already here,
they're in our communities.
117
:They're not just recent border crossers.
118
:They have been here and
they're part of our lives.
119
:So it's like, oh, you know, like, we
really want to take a look at this
120
:systemically as solutions of not
like, okay, let's deport them all.
121
:Also know that you're deporting
families and like there's gotta be
122
:this humanitarian aspect of this.
123
:It's not just that.
124
:So that's what we start with.
125
:That's what you get.
126
:Sometimes actually our guests
get this as well, so that we can
127
:have more vibrant communications,
talks about what's going on.
128
:That's the behind the scenes
and that's what we're doing
129
:this week is sort of laying out.
130
:Some of the information that we are
interested in, some of the things that we
131
:are gonna explore, and some of the people
that we want to talk with on this, whether
132
:it's policy, people or, recent immigrants,
maybe even undocumented or illegal aliens,
133
:whoever we can get around this to really
explore this and explore their things.
134
:Jerremy: Yeah.
135
:So on that kind of general topic, Dave,
earlier you mentioned the word problem,
136
:which is what we do in this podcast.
137
:Do you feel Trump was the first
president in recent decades to
138
:take a very, uh, what's the word?
139
:Overwhelming stance on immigration, and
he also proposed a very tactical solution.
140
:I'm not calling it a workable solution.
141
:I'm saying this is a solution to him.
142
:A k the wall.
143
:In your recent memory, was
this the first person to really
144
:take that type of a stance?
145
:Dave: He took, or he takes a
very energetic stance, right?
146
:Like there's a lot of energy behind what
he's saying, and it's not positive, right?
147
:Mm-hmm.
148
:You know?
149
:Mm-hmm.
150
:When he came down the escalator in
:
151
:problems you're having and these are the
people that are causing those problems.
152
:You know, it's an us versus them.
153
:And that is very polarizing, right?
154
:And that puts people very much on edge.
155
:And that is pretty much the first
time in, you know, like our living
156
:history where that's happened.
157
:It is not the case in the
United States that has actually
158
:happened many other times.
159
:Back to the colonial era,
160
:there was like this real
like, oh no, no, no, no, no.
161
:You know, like we are going to.
162
:Make sure that it is only these
kind of people like, um mm-hmm.
163
:Mid 19th century, basically we're saying,
okay, no Chinese people not allowed.
164
:Mm-hmm.
165
:But we would allow like a huge
number of Europeans, right?
166
:We had 14 million people that came in
in 40 years, which is actually more than
167
:what we've seen in the last 10, 15 years.
168
:Like, it's a huge number.
169
:It was 15% of the US population.
170
:And then, uh, in the 20th century,
again, long before we were born,
171
:there was a real bias against Southern
Europeans or eastern Europeans.
172
:Like they were, they were like, oh, no,
no, no, we're not gonna have any of this.
173
:And they actually shut down immigration
starting in about 19 20, 19 24,
174
:which I didn't realize, but like,
there wasn't a lot of immigration
175
:between the twenties and the eighties.
176
:Like there was this 60 year period.
177
:Where not much happened.
178
:We did actually allow a lot
of Mexican laborers to come
179
:in because we needed labor.
180
:And, but outside of that there was,
it was a real small number and it
181
:really was, it was quite prejudicial,
you know, like it was a lot of like,
182
:oh no, no, we're not doing that.
183
:Changed in the eighties.
184
:And, and this is, I have some memory of
this, and I wanted to ask you about this.
185
:Because I, this is how I sort of have,
you know, my thinking about immigration.
186
:It happened where I was, you know,
like how I grew up and where I grew up.
187
:Uh, and I wanted to get your, your
vibe on things like what was it like
188
:you, when you were growing up, like
what was your view of immigration?
189
:Did you have a sense of it, you
know, like where, where, where were
190
:sort of the beginnings of Jerremy
newsom's thinking on immigration?
191
:Jerremy: Sure.
192
:It really wasn't a issue, topic
or really overall thought for me.
193
:Dave: Yeah.
194
:Jerremy: Growing up in Georgia,
I would say probably the number
195
:one politically divisive topic was
probably more racism than immigration.
196
:Um, because what was interesting is in
Georgia where I grew up, immigration
197
:was very welcomed isn't the right word,
probably swept under the rug because
198
:they're like, Hey, we have a lot of jobs
199
:Dave: Yeah.
200
:Jerremy: That we need, or I
shouldn't say we need, they really
201
:want cheap labor for, right?
202
:And it was like, oh, well,
let's give cheap labor to
203
:immigrants or illegal aliens.
204
:And that was very common, very
popular in the farms, right?
205
:Picking watermelons, picking peanuts,
doing extremely hard construction work.
206
:Uh, very, very often was.
207
:Immigrants, and I didn't know if
they were illegal or not, but again,
208
:most of the farmers or owners of the
land or owners of the construction
209
:companies, they didn't really care.
210
:Dave: Yeah.
211
:Jerremy: So that's how I kind of saw it.
212
:And so I guess subconsciously, if we
had to dive deeper, my thought would've
213
:been, Hey, immigration, even if it is
illegal, is probably perfectly normal.
214
:As long as we get them jobs
and we get them working.
215
:Like that's probably
gonna help the economy.
216
:And so I think that was probably a
subconscious belief that I had and
217
:probably still have, where it's like,
listen, is there a better way to do it?
218
:Yes.
219
:But they're gonna have people that, Hey,
you want the Big American cool dream?
220
:Amazing.
221
:That dream is probably gonna be,
initiated somehow by a lot of work.
222
:And so if you want a lot of work,
we're gonna give you access to that.
223
:So if you come here looking for jobs,
looking for opportunity, looking
224
:for employment, hey, guess what?
225
:We got tons of it.
226
:Dave: Yeah.
227
:Jerremy: And I think that is probably.
228
:A way to inject excitement
into this world.
229
:And at the same time, you mentioned
earlier the solution of, okay,
230
:cool, so how do we do that?
231
:Dave: Mm-hmm.
232
:Jerremy: Um, that was really
kind of my upbringing.
233
:What about yours?
234
:Dave: So I grew up just outside
of Washington DC and it was a real
235
:turning point in immigration actually.
236
:There was a lot of stuff happening
around Vietnam at the time.
237
:There was a big humanitarian crisis and
we had, what was called boat people.
238
:A lot of churches got together with
politicians and be like, oh my God.
239
:We have all these boat people
and 'cause they were primarily
240
:Christians actually fleeing poverty.
241
:And there was droughts and all, you know,
like huge things that were going on.
242
:I mean, they'd just gotten outta
the Vietnam War and now they were
243
:having humanitarian crisis and
a lot of 'em were Christians.
244
:And so a lot of the churches in the
United States actually like, were
245
:pounding on the doors of, particularly
Republicans and Reagan to be like, oh
246
:my God, we've gotta rescue these folks.
247
:And so they did.
248
:And the State Department scooped
up tens of thousands of Vietnamese,
249
:and they dropped them in three
places in the United States.
250
:One of them was in Los Angeles,
the other one was Houston, Texas.
251
:And, the third one was.
252
:Right outside where I lived
in Falls Church, Virginia.
253
:And in fact, falls Church still has one
of the largest Vietnamese populations in
254
:the United States, outside of Vietnam.
255
:To this day, my comfort
food is Vietnamese food.
256
:Every time I'm back in DC I'm like,
I'm going for Vietnamese food.
257
:I love it.
258
:Right.
259
:And so my friends, a lot
of them were Vietnamese.
260
:And then just down the road
in Annandale, Virginia, there
261
:was a huge Korean population.
262
:You know, they had had the war in the
fifties, but they'd also, uh, lived in
263
:sort of like this strange, like communist
sort of like disaster in South Korea.
264
:You know, South Korea being a
democracy is actually pretty new.
265
:I, you know, I don't think a
lot of people realize that.
266
:And so a lot of refugees from Korea came
and they were deposited again by the
267
:State Department in Annandale, Virginia.
268
:And then outside of that, not a lot
of, um, Mexican laborers but a lot of
269
:people from other nations in Central
and South America, a lot of Honduras, a
270
:lot of Venezuelan, uh, some Brazilian.
271
:So like, it wasn't a
lot of, of, of Mexican.
272
:Like what, what you would, you know,
see in, in Texas or in California.
273
:The south.
274
:Yeah.
275
:Yeah.
276
:Mainly in the south.
277
:But it wasn't like an agrarian area.
278
:It was the suburbs.
279
:Right.
280
:And here's what was nuts again,
this is a history that I don't
281
:think a lot of people realize.
282
:All these Vietnamese come into the
United States and with a stroke of a
283
:pen, a fine Republican, Ronald Reagan
made tens of thousands of Vietnamese.
284
:Instant citizens.
285
:I mean, instant like, just signed
and said you're an American.
286
:That was pretty much my
upbringing because, you know,
287
:DC was incredibly multicultural.
288
:I was surrounded by, you know,
people that weren't like me.
289
:You know, like a lot of Vietnamese,
a lot of Korean, a lot of Asian, and
290
:DC being very, you know, just like
everybody's from everywhere else.
291
:And that really was my thinking
around, like, it wasn't a thing.
292
:It just like people existed.
293
:And you know, like looking at
how polarizing it is today, I
294
:didn't grow up with any of that.
295
:You know, everybody was just there.
296
:And like, there was plenty of work.
297
:Like it was an abundance thing, you
know, it's like there was plenty of
298
:work you know, like, particularly the
Vietnamese and the Koreans as a population
299
:they, they really fundamentally changed
Northern Virginia, which was like this,
300
:sleepy little, slightly southern, part
301
:of Washington DC completely transformed
it into like, a lot of stores, a lot of
302
:entrepreneurship, you know, just, it just,
it completely changed the fabric of the
303
:area and made it really amazing actually.
304
:I mean, to this day I
love going through there.
305
:It's like, it's a really special
part of the United States.
306
:And so that was, that was sort
of my foundation, which was
307
:like these folks are just here.
308
:And by the way to this day, you know,
some of the most patriotic people I
309
:know, because a lot of folks that became
instant US citizens, because it was
310
:Washington DC and it was a company town,
a lot of them joined the government.
311
:And so when I joined the government
30 years later, I was surrounded
312
:by Koreans and Vietnamese.
313
:Yeah.
314
:Uh, who had now been in the
government and their parents had
315
:been in the government for, 40 years.
316
:And I'm like, okay, this is awesome.
317
:So, you know, my views
were always very positive.
318
:Uh, you know, there wasn't, you
know, sort of an underclass.
319
:I'd say it changed, you know, I left
DC I think, uh, 10, 15 years ago now.
320
:And what was really clear was and
actually a lot of people in the
321
:government got in trouble for this,
which was hiring people under the table.
322
:And so, like, can you imagine
like, this was the thing that got
323
:a politician, like, ousted or like
a senior executive out, right.
324
:Because they, they had a, they had
a nanny or they had somebody who was
325
:like mowing their lawn who was like
undocumented their pan under the table.
326
:You know, like that was the thing
that would ruin people's careers.
327
:Now, you know, not so much.
328
:So like, there really is, underneath now,
this world of people who just work under
329
:the table, which is now one of my issues.
330
:And I think we can talk about that maybe
next of what are the problems that we see,
331
:you know, like now they, this was my, my
foundation was like, hey this is awesome.
332
:And that's evolved.
333
:Jerremy: Yep.
334
:Alex: "From Dave’s multicultural DC roots
to Jerremy’s Georgia farm days, we’ve
335
:uncovered how history and personal stories
shape America’s immigration debate.
336
:But knowing where we’ve been
is just the start—what’s next?
337
:In our upcoming episode, we dig into the
bold solutions that could redefine our
338
:borders, from economic game-changers to
foreign policy fixes that hit at the root.
339
:You won’t want to miss it."