America's Voting Crisis: Fraud Fears, Gerrymandering, and the Path to Real Reform
Jerremy and Dave explore civic duty as a virtue, spotlighting guest Tyler's take on voting as personal integrity and Rob Richie's push for ranked choice voting. They dissect why many—especially youth—skip elections, proposing bold shifts like making voting "cool," mandatory participation, incentives, and a national holiday to transform apathy into action and amplify every voice in democracy.
Timestamps:
- (00:00) Reflections: Barriers and Hopes for Voting Reform
- (06:31) Voter Apathy: Unpacking Why People Skip Elections
- (09:49) Impact Factor: The Real Power of Individual Votes
- (10:32) Electoral College Critique: Weighing Its Role Today
- (13:11) Engagement Boost: Ideas to Make Voting Accessible and Fun
📢 Solving America’s Problems Podcast – Real Solutions For Real Issues
Transcript
And here we are.
2
:Jerremy: Yes.
3
:kickoff to ballot box number three,
4
:Rethinking Who Votes in America.
5
:That was fun.
6
:Everyone.
7
:Dave: We say that every time.
8
:That was fun.
9
:Jerremy: Yeah.
10
:Everyone loves our wrap-ups.
11
:The, what did we learn?
12
:Where did we go?
13
:What did we study?
14
:Who did we hear from?
15
:Dave: Yeah,
16
:Jerremy: And I felt like we did a
really unique job of spraying this
17
:up over many weeks, many days,
18
:Dave: we did.
19
:Jerremy: many months.
20
:Hear, hearing from different
people, hearing different thoughts,
21
:hearing different ideas, concerns.
22
:I actually ended up meeting with Reed
in person in Vegas like two weeks ago.
23
:Dave: Nice.
24
:Jerremy: So we had some some
more good follow-up conversation,
25
:but yeah, I enjoyed it, man.
26
:I think it'd be fun for people to
learn or hear about where you started
27
:when we entered this, like where
you were at on this whole journey.
28
:Dave: I think like a lot of people I
I started with this general feeling,
29
:Hey, this isn't working, this doesn't
work, this isn't working for me.
30
:The, this whole voting thing,
this just seems ridiculous.
31
:And then you don't know what to believe
with oh, voting fraud and hanging chads
32
:and like there's been nothing but voting
fraud as the, it seems like the highest
33
:best use of political capital since 2016.
34
:It's just been Russians
and stuffed ballot boxes.
35
:And nobody feels good about that, right?
36
:It's like you want your vote to
count and yet underneath it all,
37
:like I knew things weren't right
with things like gerrymandering.
38
:And that came up over and over again.
39
:So it felt very, like the
process was broken for me, right?
40
:It's and there's a, there's
this this creeping ni nihilism,
41
:I don't know how to say it,
42
:Of well who watches the watchers, if the
people who are in charge of this, or the
43
:ones in charge of reforming it, and it's
in their best interest to keep it exactly
44
:the same because they wanna stay in power,
like it gets dark really quick, right?
45
:Jerremy: Yeah.
46
:Dave: So I, I think that's, I started in
that space of, okay, this is a problem.
47
:Everybody knows it's a problem
and we can't do anything about it.
48
:And that did evolve for me, I'd say.
49
:How about you?
50
:Where did you start in this?
51
:Jerremy: I started I believe from the, and
I probably have a lot of this still, but
52
:definitely started from the perspective
of we need more data, more numbers.
53
:A little bit more strictness to it and
more sure, let's call it protocols.
54
:Putting very strategic things in place.
55
:And one of the, one of the aspects that
definitely shifted in a nice way was
56
:the like national holiday for voting.
57
:Dave: Yeah.
58
:Jerremy: That's actually probably
a really great way to make it
59
:more standardized, to make it more
available, to make it more open so that
60
:everyone does take off work from it
and they actually have access to it.
61
:And that aspect, you have the
ability to track more data
62
:Dave: Yeah.
63
:Jerremy: again, with AI and technology,
just make it a little bit more seamless.
64
:I do think that there's still, I
don't think we've solved for that yet.
65
:With all the different ways
to vote, with like mail-in
66
:ballots and so on and so forth.
67
:But I do believe that there's some
something there where it's one or
68
:two more deep dives into the do
we track, how do we know for sure?
69
:Did these people vote or not?
70
:Dave: Yeah.
71
:Jerremy: especially if you were registered
to vote and you didn't vote, why not?
72
:If you did register to vote and you
voted awesome, like I don't really.
73
:Worry about personally having
that data being shared.
74
:I think that could be something
that'd be very easy to be privatized
75
:Secure way.
76
:But yeah, man I did, I enjoyed it.
77
:I enjoyed the journey.
78
:It was really fun to just
have that conversation.
79
:I definitely was convinced that stricter
identification and process integrity
80
:were central to voter confidence.
81
:And I still see slash saw civic
participation through a lens
82
:of individual responsibility
and procedural rigorousness.
83
:Dave: yeah.
84
:Yeah.
85
:Jerremy: So it it enjoyable to know that
I, after, and we'll get to it later,
86
:but speaking to Rob, there's definitely
people who really care about the process,
87
:Dave: Yeah.
88
:Jerremy: about the numbers, who do
care about the data, who do truly
89
:are putting in the mathematical
sequences to figure this stuff out.
90
:get really dialed in.
91
:Dave: That's, I didn't participate
in the discussion was wrong.
92
:I was in the background for those
of you, I think we addressed it
93
:a little bit at the top of this.
94
:These are launching right
now as we're recording this.
95
:I was there, but I, as you can hear
from my voice I'm still recovering a
96
:bit from a wee bit of a virus that,
that that grabbed me and held me down.
97
:But I was listening to it and I
was re-listening to Rob and I.
98
:I love that we have advocates that
are so passionate about that he's
99
:devoted his entire life to this.
100
:And that's the piece that
gives me hope, right?
101
:It tamps down that, that nihilism
of oh, we can't do anything when
102
:we like, oh, but we have people
and he's made big changes with the
103
:proportionate voting, the rank choice,
voting, those things have happened.
104
:And the one that, that is, I think
the easiest one that we can do that
105
:would actually help quite a bit
would be that national holiday.
106
:That's gonna be a hard one.
107
:Not for people, for anybody in
power to say that's a bad idea.
108
:Like that's an easy one.
109
:And it's not one of those direct
fixes, but it's on the side of it.
110
:It'll be like, okay, if we're getting
more people to, to participate.
111
:We're gonna have more people
who are going to want reform.
112
:I think approaching voting reform head
on is a, is it is just, it's always
113
:going to hit up against the people
who are gonna wanna keep it the same.
114
:So we have to like, we have to hit
at it at the side and the is gonna
115
:be like national holiday, that means
we're gonna get more people involved.
116
:That means with more voices, more
people, more power around that, then
117
:that will lead to bigger, better things.
118
:And I think that's my favorite
one that came out of all of this,
119
:which was, yeah, national holiday.
120
:That seems like an easy win.
121
:Jerremy: That's exactly from all
the things we discussed, that does
122
:seem pretty pretty reasonable.
123
:Dave: Yeah.
124
:Jerremy: You can't Hey,
you wanna change voting?
125
:Why do you wanna change voting?
126
:'cause you like to vote.
127
:It makes a lot of sense.
128
:It's a national, let's make it a holiday
129
:Dave: Totally.
130
:Jerremy: because it's once every what,
two years, let's probably say that would.
131
:Dave: Yeah.
132
:In November, it'd be like we can bump
it up near Thanksgiving maybe, or maybe
133
:it's a, may maybe it'd be the what,
the second Tuesday in November, right?
134
:Jerremy: Yeah,
135
:Dave: Or first Tuesday in November.
136
:I don't know which one it is.
137
:Jerremy: Tuesday of November.
138
:Dave: Tuesday in November, right?
139
:Yeah, that sounds good to me.
140
:Jerremy: Hey, I like it, man.
141
:Let's just make that, let's
just push that law through.
142
:Dave: I think that's an easy one.
143
:I think we can actually
make that one happen, right?
144
:That feels very doable, gets
more people involved, people
145
:who wanna have the day off.
146
:They can just have the day off.
147
:We can make parties out of it.
148
:We can, have voting drives.
149
:There's so many things.
150
:I, I hear you on the ID thing, and I,
we, we talked to Reed, we talked to
151
:oh, we talked to, oh, Tyler, right?
152
:We've talked about ID a few times
and, like I live here in, in Florida
153
:where, strict id you have to show it.
154
:I do hear, and I heard it a bit
from from our last guest of yeah.
155
:Like there are still a bunch of
people who don't have IDs and
156
:that's a significant barrier.
157
:I still keep coming back to
where we landed on it, which
158
:is let's fix that problem.
159
:Everybody should have an id.
160
:Let's make it inexpensive, easy.
161
:Let's have the ID buses in all of the
neighborhoods that need to have them.
162
:It's like having an ID is pretty
basic, pretty straightforward, and I
163
:think we can overcome those objections
by fixing the ID part of this.
164
:I think there's always gonna be edge
cases of people who may not, if they're
165
:just new to the country and they
don't have some source documentation,
166
:but you can get there, right?
167
:You can get there with
Hey, this is who I am.
168
:I test who I am, this is how I
get a gas bill, this address,
169
:this is, on and on, right?
170
:My buddy Jerremy says, this is who I am.
171
:So
172
:Jerremy: Yeah.
173
:Dave: I think let's fix the ID
thing, but let's fix it separately.
174
:And then you can definitely
use it for things like voting.
175
:And I think it's okay to tie
those things together, I think.
176
:I think you're all for that, right?
177
:Jerremy: I'm all for that.
178
:Yep.
179
:I'm, that's, I vote yes.
180
:Hearing Yeah.
181
:Tyler talk about it and Reed and Rob and
really all from different perspectives.
182
:I was intrigued to learn how many people
had a relatively strong opinion on it.
183
:Outside of our three guests,
there were a lot of people that
184
:were like, no, don't do that.
185
:'cause you're gonna disenfranchise
or you're gonna, you're gonna
186
:create too much separation.
187
:Or there's a lot of people that
don't have that, and that's unfair.
188
:And I do exactly agree with what
you said, and I think really what
189
:we said is, man, we can fix that.
190
:That's
191
:Dave: Yeah,
192
:Jerremy: right?
193
:Dave: easy,
194
:Jerremy: get everyone an ID
195
:Dave: right?
196
:Jerremy: and then just
make it a requirement
197
:Dave: It's gonna be free,
you can't afford it.
198
:Here's your id.
199
:Great.
200
:It doesn't even have to be a
driver's license or anything.
201
:It'd just be like, like walking around
Id, this is you, this is who you are.
202
:You can use it for all sort of things.
203
:You can use it to, to check out books
at your library, whatever, right?
204
:Jerremy: All kinds of things.
205
:Having an idea, like if
you want to go to the gym,
206
:Dave: That was the story.
207
:You couldn't go work out
because you didn't have your.
208
:Jerremy: go work out at Lifetime
Fitness in Laguna Beach, California
209
:Dave: Yeah.
210
:Jerremy: buddies,
211
:Dave: Nope.
212
:Jerremy: don't have an id.
213
:You can't get jacked without an id.
214
:So you need some.
215
:So that is a, am a.
216
:Legal system of the us I think that's
just a valid, useful thing to have.
217
:Dave: Yeah
218
:Jerremy: I do agree with, I think
Reid was really one who brought up.
219
:It was like I really don't think, illegal
immigrants are flooding to the booths
220
:and making a bunch of votes anyway.
221
:And I agree with that.
222
:I don't think that's
223
:Dave: We talked about that too, and
I think I'm a little bit more liberal
224
:on this, meaning that regardless
of your legal status whether you're
225
:a citizen or not, let's just leave
it at that US citizen versus not.
226
:You live here, right?
227
:You have a vested interest
by living in your community.
228
:I am totally fine.
229
:With regardless of immigration status,
if you are a student from someplace
230
:else, if you are, a permanent resident,
if you're like, whatever it is, you are
231
:here in the United States and you are
here for the next one year, five year
232
:indefinitely, whatever it is, right?
233
:You have a ve vested
interest in your community.
234
:So yeah, you should be able to
vote in your local elections.
235
:You should be able to vote in
your county-wide stuff, and who's
236
:gonna be collecting your garbage
and picking up stray dogs and your
237
:local ordinances on, on, on noise.
238
:And like all of that stuff is a
part of you and your community.
239
:And then maybe states can
decide whether or not you can
240
:do state, level stuff or not.
241
:I tend to think yeah, that, regardless
of your status, you should be able to
242
:do state stuff when it gets to be like
federal and your federal representation.
243
:Yeah, I think that really is for citizens.
244
:I don't know why I feel that
way, but it just, it that
245
:feels more you're an American.
246
:So you're voting on America, like
I'm of the mindset that like,
247
:if you live in a community, you
should be able to vote in community
248
:regardless of your quote unquote,
249
:Jerremy: yeah, I
250
:Dave: nation of origin,
251
:Jerremy: no, I actually
love that perspective.
252
:I love that perspective.
253
:I think it would be more of a, again,
from the ID perspective of if people
254
:have, this is who I am, are you?
255
:If you're a student, you're
like, oh, I walk into the thing.
256
:Here's my student visa.
257
:Oh, you're here legally.
258
:Dave: Yeah.
259
:Jerremy: Anyone who's here illegally,
260
:Dave: Yeah.
261
:Jerremy: yeah, absolutely.
262
:Vote in anything local.
263
:'cause you live here.
264
:Dave: You live here,
265
:Jerremy: You're buying food, you're buying
266
:Dave: right?
267
:Jerremy: so you're
268
:Dave: Yeah,
269
:Jerremy: all that good stuff.
270
:If you're here illegally, I don't
think you should be voting in anything.
271
:Dave: really?
272
:I don't know.
273
:I don't care about the
legal status all that much.
274
:'cause going back to
our immigration debate,
275
:Jerremy: Yep.
276
:Dave: Let's fix the, let's fix
the, everybody's here to work, so
277
:let's fix it on the working side.
278
:And I, so I'm like, look, if
it, regardless, I really am.
279
:It's regardless of status, if
you live in an area, you should
280
:be able to vote on something.
281
:I dunno.
282
:Jerremy: what I like when Reid was
essentially saying there hasn't really
283
:ever been a specific, influx or a
diatribe of very particular people.
284
:They're like, let's
totally swing something.
285
:'cause we're all, we're illegal and
we're all gonna vote this one way and
286
:we're gonna bring in a cartel member.
287
:he's gonna become, he's
gonna become mayor,
288
:Dave: That would be interesting.
289
:Okay.
290
:Yeah, I can imagine some
scenarios where I might backtrack.
291
:Jerremy: But soft scenarios.
292
:Dave: Right.
293
:Jerremy: 'cause, because, yeah, I
think it's just again, back to the
294
:ID part, that just seems so easy
295
:Dave: So straightforward.
296
:Jerremy: Yeah.
297
:Everyone could just get lucky.
298
:I'm a human and I really like living here.
299
:It's a great country.
300
:Here's an id, I am that person.
301
:Yeah, it'd be really fun.
302
:Make it makes Starbucks
orders a lot easier.
303
:You can just show them your card.
304
:Hey, here's my, here's who I am,
here's how my name is spelled.
305
:And then the Starbucks
barista writes it correctly.
306
:Dave: I can already hear the civil
libertarians in our audience.
307
:Just dying on the inside
going, no, I don't watch an id.
308
:No.
309
:Jerremy: Well, I.
310
:But they already, the civil
libertarians already have an id, right?
311
:Dave: But it's in your name, right?
312
:Jerremy: Yeah.
313
:It's good times.
314
:Good times.
315
:Dave: So yeah we talked to Reid.
316
:That was great.
317
:That was God that feels so long ago.
318
:Then we talked to Tyler.
319
:Jerremy: Yep.
320
:Both are fun.
321
:Yeah.
322
:Reid's a civic observer.
323
:Had he just, he loved it.
324
:He's in it.
325
:He loves talking politics.
326
:We sat down for breakfast,
three minutes in boom.
327
:Politics.
328
:It was like politics and stocks and money.
329
:That was the breakfast conversation.
330
:And it was nice.
331
:It was interesting that he illustrated how
distrust elections is cultivated, right?
332
:It's not really accidental, which makes.
333
:Perfect sense.
334
:And he definitely positioned himself
in a way that gerrymandering the
335
:foundational democratic flaw.
336
:And
337
:Dave: It is it the deep wound?
338
:When it gets down to it, we didn't
find, I, maybe next time I'm gonna find
339
:somebody who's yeah, gerrymandering.
340
:Go gerrymandering.
341
:Jerremy: It's the best.
342
:I love salamanders.
343
:Yeah.
344
:Dave: It's yeah, I don't think we're,
again, that's just like people wanting
345
:to stay in power for the sake of power.
346
:And that's all, partisan politics.
347
:And it has nothing to
do with representation.
348
:It has nothing to do that's when
it, it feels the most to me,
349
:that, our representatives care
the least about us when it affects
350
:their ability to keep their job.
351
:Jerremy: On gerrymandering.
352
:You said ah let's find someone
that made this awesome.
353
:Dave: Oh
354
:Who watches the watchers?
355
:Like I, is, we're seeing it now
with, states wanting to redistrict
356
:right now in time for, for midterms
coming up this time next year.
357
:So California's gonna add,
Florida's gonna add, Texas is
358
:gonna add, new York's gonna add.
359
:Everybody's gonna add like a
bunch of representatives, try
360
:and balance each other out and
try to get like the upper hand.
361
:None of it actually serves
any of the voters at all.
362
:This is just, as politicians
being politicians,
363
:Jerremy: Yep.
364
:Dave: I fixing gerrymandering isn't
going to be a thing that we can do.
365
:Not until we, we take it out
of the hands of politicians,
366
:Jerremy: Yeah.
367
:Dave: Like that's, this
is not gonna be it.
368
:Jerremy: Un unless unless we have
an AI redraw borders or something.
369
:Dave: I love it.
370
:But then
371
:Jerremy: But again, you gotta
take it outta the hands.
372
:Yeah.
373
:Dave: be like, okay.
374
:Yeah
375
:Jerremy: hey Jerry, you can't draw
your district lines in North Carolina.
376
:Dave: And you brought this up, I think
more than once, you brought it up with,
377
:I think in every single one of ours,
which is look we already have counties.
378
:Like, why what's the deal here?
379
:Like why do we have anything else?
380
:But, and man, that makes
so much more sense to me.
381
:And like for Miami-Dade for the
county, I, because of how many million
382
:people live here, I would just get,
five representatives that would
383
:Jerremy: Yep.
384
:Dave: Miami-Dade, and it's not,
like this particular district, it's
385
:this county like, and all five of
'em, and in a more sparse area, they
386
:might have two or three counties.
387
:And that, I don't know that seems
so straightforward, so simple.
388
:It's like we don't need gerrymandering.
389
:We already have
390
:Jerremy: Correct.
391
:Dave: boundaries.
392
:They're already
393
:Jerremy: They're already there.
394
:They're already drawn.
395
:Just stop with the politic games.
396
:Yeah.
397
:So that that one's, that's the
one that I'm, I love that we
398
:both beautifully agree on that.
399
:That also sounds really easy.
400
:And you know what?
401
:It's pretty straightforward, right?
402
:All that stuff is already done.
403
:It's already there.
404
:It's already outlined for us.
405
:There's not a lot of whole, not
a lot of work that we need to do.
406
:Dave: Yeah.
407
:Jerremy: So that was nice.
408
:Alex: Dave digs into gerrymandering's
deep wounds on fair representation,
409
:while Jerremy pushes for using
existing county lines to cut the games.
410
:Yet if politicians redraw boundaries
to cling to power, what chance do
411
:voters have to reclaim the map?
